If you ask Oprah, the answer is yes. She has remarked that many of her wealthiest friends, wealthy by almost any benchmark, own their homes outright. There is a powerful psychological appeal to that idea. Having carried a number of mortgages over the years and having paid off a few while still owning those properties, I can attest that the feeling of owning a home free and clear is remarkable. It lifts a kind of background financial stress that many people do not fully register until it is gone.

But the story rarely ends there. In my own case, we later purchased a larger apartment, rolled equity forward, and took on a new mortgage, this time at a fixed rate secured during the pandemic. The rate is so low I hesitate to say it out loud for fear of causing envy. I had historically favored variable loans, reasoning that most homeowners move within five to ten years anyway, so why not take the lower, riskier rate? In this case, I was “persuaded” (by my spouse) to opt for a fixed rate. I am grateful we did, given what transpired with interest rates over the following years.

All of which leads to the real question: should you pay your mortgage off, or keep it?

Step One: Look at Your Current Rate

Before thinking about feelings, start with the math.

Mortgage debt is often called “good debt” because:

• The interest is typically tax deductible (subject to limits and your specific tax situation).
• Each payment builds equity over time, even if only modestly at the beginning.

By contrast, high‑interest credit card balances and other non‑deductible consumer debt are classic examples of “bad debt”—expensive and offering no tax offset.

With that in mind, your interest rate becomes the key starting point.

• If your mortgage rate is below 4%, and especially below 3%, you are sitting on not just good debt, but great debt. In today’s world, it is difficult for low‑risk investments to consistently beat such a cheap cost of borrowing. From a strictly mathematical perspective, the argument for keeping that mortgage and investing excess cash elsewhere is strong.
• If your rate is in the 5% to 7% range, the analysis becomes more nuanced. A 6% mortgage is not extreme by historical standards; it is actually close to long‑term averages. The key questions are:
  • Can you reliably earn more than 6% elsewhere without taking on risk that makes you uncomfortable?
  • How does your after‑tax mortgage rate compare to the after‑tax return of other investments?
• If your rate is above 7%, it is worth exploring options. That could mean:
  • Refinancing, if a 1% or greater rate improvement is realistically available.
  • Considering accelerated payoff or a lump‑sum reduction if you have the means and the alternatives for that cash are not compelling.

Rate levels do not dictate the answer on their own, but they frame the conversation.

The Liquidity Question: Where Will Your Cash Live?

When you pay down or pay off your mortgage, you are converting liquid assets (cash or investments) into a relatively illiquid asset: your home.

That has important implications:

• If you use a large portion of your savings to eliminate the mortgage, what happens if you face an unexpected expense—a health issue, a job change, a family need, or a business opportunity?
• How easily could you access that money again?
  • Pulling cash out of your home usually requires refinancing or a home equity loan.
  • For co‑op owners, those tools can be more restrictive and slower to arrange.

Most thoughtful financial advisors will recommend that you do not drain your liquid reserves in the name of paying off a mortgage. Maintaining a healthy cash buffer—often many months of expenses—is critical for flexibility and peace of mind.

The “Guaranteed Return” You Get From Paying Down Debt

One of the more compelling cases for paying down a mortgage is the certainty it offers.

If your mortgage rate is 6%, every dollar you put toward principal generates a 6% return in a very specific sense:

• It is risk‑free: you are eliminating an obligation, not speculating.
• It is effectively tax‑free: you are not incurring taxable investment income.
• It is predictable: you know exactly what you are saving in interest.

That kind of guaranteed return is hard to find elsewhere, particularly once you factor in taxes on investment gains. Just as the mortgage interest deduction lowers your effective borrowing rate, taxes on investment income lower your effective investment return.

For some people, that promise of a known, steady “return” via debt reduction feels more attractive than chasing higher, but uncertain, returns in the market.

The Psychological Side: Peace of Mind vs Productive Leverage

Numbers aside, there is a very human dimension to this question.

Mortgages are mathematical instruments. Homes are emotional ones.

In working with clients, I have seen both ends of the spectrum:

• Some people light up at the idea of living debt‑free. For them, eliminating the mortgage unlocks a sense of safety and independence that no spreadsheet can fully capture. This can be especially powerful for those approaching or in retirement, when fixed expenses feel more burdensome.
• Others feel energized by keeping capital working for them—investing, building businesses, or preserving liquidity for opportunities. They are comfortable with well‑structured leverage and view the mortgage as a tool.

Both views are valid. For many younger buyers and growing families, mortgage leverage is precisely what makes long‑term wealth building possible, allowing them to own property in a market that might otherwise be out of reach. For many older owners, paying off—or significantly paying down—the loan is about simplifying life and reducing monthly obligations.

So, Should You Pay Your Mortgage Off?

1. There is no one‑size‑fits‑all answer. But a few guiding questions can help:
2. What is your current interest rate (and effective rate after taxes)?
3. How strong is your cash cushion after any payoff or principal reduction?
4. What alternative uses for your money do you have—and what are their realistic, risk‑adjusted returns?
5. How close are you to retirement or other major life transitions?
6. How much does the idea of being mortgage‑free matter to you emotionally?

If you are fortunate enough to be considering paying your mortgage off—or paying it down aggressively—it likely means you have done many things right already. The “best” decision is the one that balances risk, opportunity, and peace of mind in a way that fits your life, not just your calculator.

And whatever you decide, here’s hoping that your future mortgage rates are low, your investment returns are high, and your weekend experiences remain richly rewarding.

Read the full newsletter →