Preload Spinner

How Much Apartment Can You Afford in NYC? Co-op vs. Condo Costs, Income Requirements, and Buying Power

BACK

How Much Apartment Can You Afford in NYC? Co-op vs. Condo Costs, Income Requirements, and Buying Power

In New York City, how much apartment you can afford is set by two tests, not one: what a lender will lend, and, in a co-op, what the board will approve. Fannie Mae’s underwriting guide allows total debt payments of up to 45% of income, or 50% through its automated system, while most NYC co-op boards look for 25% to 30%, according to StreetEasy. Boards also expect at least 20% down and often up to two years of housing costs in the bank after closing. Below, I walk through each test and a worked example at today’s rate.

Living room of a prewar Manhattan co-op apartment with tall windows and city views
In a co-op, the board’s financial test can matter as much as the lender’s.

Key takeaways

  • Most NYC co-op boards look for a debt-to-income ratio of 25% to 30%, which is tighter than the limits in Fannie Mae’s lending guide.
  • Plan on at least 20% down for a co-op and at least 10% for most condos. Some co-ops ask for 25% or more.
  • Many co-ops want one to two years of mortgage and maintenance payments in liquid assets after closing, and some Manhattan buildings want more.
  • Your monthly cost is the mortgage plus co-op maintenance, or the mortgage plus condo common charges and real estate taxes, plus insurance.
  • At Freddie Mac’s 30-year average of 7.18% (November 5, 2026), a $1,000,000 loan costs about $6,775 a month in principal and interest.

Can I afford to buy in New York City if the bank approves me?

Not necessarily. A preapproval tells you what a lender will finance. In a co-op, the board applies its own test, which is usually stricter.

Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide (version dated April 2, 2025) sets a maximum total debt-to-income ratio of 36% for manually underwritten loans. That can go up to 45% for borrowers who meet its credit score and reserve requirements, and its automated underwriting system allows up to 50%.

Co-op boards are tighter. StreetEasy reports that the majority of NYC co-ops look for a debt-to-income ratio between 25% and 30%. A Warburg Realty broker quoted in the article says 28% or less is more acceptable, and the strictest co-ops want something closer to 20%. Boards count the new mortgage and maintenance along with debts you already carry, such as car loans, student loans, and credit card payments, and divide by gross income.

How much do I need for a down payment on a NYC co-op or condo?

Plan on at least 20% down for a co-op and at least 10% for most condos, according to StreetEasy’s July 2026 guide to buying costs.

Many co-ops ask for more. StreetEasy’s first-time buyer guide notes that many co-ops allow only 75% financing, which means 25% down, and that some have cut their maximum to 70%. Its debt-to-income article says a co-op buyer might have to put up to 40% down. On the condo side, the same guide says some new development condos allow up to 90% financing.

How much cash do co-op boards want to see after closing?

Many co-ops want enough liquid assets after closing to cover one to two years of housing costs. StreetEasy’s July 2026 article on post-closing liquidity calls two years of maintenance, mortgage, and other debt payments relatively standard, and says exclusive buildings expect more. Its example: at $15,000 a month in maintenance, which it calls not at all unusual on Fifth Avenue, a board would look for $360,000 or more.

Liquidity is counted after the down payment and closing costs. Cash, stocks, bonds, Treasury securities, mutual funds, and money market funds generally count. StreetEasy notes that retirement accounts are not always considered liquid, so ask how the building treats them before you apply.

What goes into the monthly cost of owning an apartment in NYC?

Monthly cost Co-op Condo
Mortgage principal and interest Yes Yes
Building charges Maintenance, which includes your share of the building’s real estate taxes Common charges
Real estate taxes Included in maintenance Billed separately to you
Insurance Your own apartment policy Your own apartment policy

For the mortgage, I use Freddie Mac’s Primary Mortgage Market Survey. As of November 5, 2026, the 30-year fixed rate averaged 7.18%, down from 7.24% the week before, and the 15-year fixed rate averaged 6.57%. Rates change weekly, so rerun the math with your lender’s quote. If the maintenance on a listing looks high, I explain what it pays for in my post on Manhattan maintenance fees.

What does the math look like on a $1,250,000 co-op?

This is an illustration, not a quote. I use $1,250,000 because it was the Manhattan median sale price in the third quarter of 2026, according to The Corcoran Report. For context, the same report put the resale co-op median at $875,000 and the resale condo median at $1,650,000. The maintenance and insurance figures below are assumptions, not data.

Item Illustration
Purchase price $1,250,000
Down payment (20%) $250,000
Loan (30-year fixed at 7.18%) $1,000,000
Principal and interest About $6,775 a month
Maintenance (assumed) $2,500 a month
Apartment insurance (assumed) $100 a month
Total monthly carrying cost About $9,375 a month

Here is how the board’s tests play out on those numbers:

  1. Debt-to-income. Mortgage plus maintenance is about $9,275 a month, or about $111,300 a year. To stay at 30%, you would need gross income of about $371,000 ($111,300 divided by 0.30). At 25%, you would need about $445,000. Any other debts raise those figures.
  2. Post-closing liquidity. One year of mortgage and maintenance is about $111,300. Two years is about $222,600.
  3. Cash to close and qualify. The $250,000 down payment, plus the 1% mansion tax of $12,500 on a purchase of $1 million or more, plus one to two years of liquidity, comes to about $373,800 to $485,100, before attorney, lender, and building fees.

StreetEasy’s rule of thumb is that buyers pay roughly 4% to 6% of the price in closing costs, and co-op buyers skip the mortgage recording tax. I break down each line in my guide to NYC closing costs and transfer taxes.

Is a condo easier to afford than a co-op?

A condo is usually more flexible on financing, but not always cheaper. Most condos accept less down, and instead of a board interview, a condo typically only has to waive its right of first refusal, which StreetEasy says takes a few days to a month.

The trade-off is price and closing costs. Corcoran’s third quarter median for Manhattan resale condos was nearly double the resale co-op median, and condo buyers who finance pay the mortgage recording tax and title insurance.

What do I tell my clients about setting a budget?

I tell buyers to set their budget by the monthly cost and the cash left after closing, not by the asking price. A preapproval letter is a starting point, not a budget.

  1. Run the board’s math before the bank’s. If you clear 25% to 30% with room to spare, you have options in most buildings.
  2. Ask for the building’s down payment, debt-to-income, and liquidity requirements before you make an offer.
  3. Price the rate as it is today, not as you hope it will be.

If you are still deciding whether to buy at all, start with my post on renting vs. buying in Manhattan. First-time buyers should also look at the first-time buyer programs available in Manhattan.

I talk through how co-op boards look at a buyer’s finances in this short video.

If you are planning a purchase in Manhattan or Brooklyn and want to know what you can comfortably carry in the buildings you like, request a confidential consultation. For my quarterly read on the market, sign up for The Franco Report.


About the author. Michael J. Franco leads the Michael J. Franco Team at Compass and is a co-founding member of Compass’s Trusts and Estates Division. In the RealTrends Verified rankings of 2025 sales, his small team ranked No. 1 in Manhattan by number of closed sales and No. 152 in the U.S. by sales volume. He has more than 20 years of experience as a broker, attorney, and investor.

This post is for general information and is not financial, legal, or tax advice. Compass is a licensed real estate broker. Equal Housing Opportunity.