Preload Spinner

Real Estate Commissions in Manhattan: What Sellers Pay in 2026

BACK

Real Estate Commissions in Manhattan: What Sellers Pay in 2026

With 6.1 months of supply and only 14% of homes selling above list, the commission term worth a seller’s negotiating energy in Manhattan is how the buyer-agent share gets handled, not the headline rate.

Key Takeaway

Manhattan sellers still pay a total commission in the typical range. The term to negotiate first, though, is how the buyer’s agent gets paid. One percentage point on the borough’s median sale price is worth about twice what a typical seller gives up between list and sale price. If you’d rather keep a full buyer-agent offer to draw represented buyers, negotiate the listing side with a tiered fee instead.

Who This Guide Is For

You’re preparing to sell a Manhattan apartment or house and deciding what commission to agree to and whether to offer the buyer’s agent a share.

What Manhattan Sellers Pay in Real Estate Commissions

Typical commission rates in Manhattan

Analysis of over 2,000 recent home sales found that in Manhattan the typical buyer-agent commission is 3% and the typical total commission is 6%, higher than in other New York City boroughs. Across NYC the total typically runs from 5% up to that figure. It is usually split equally between the listing brokerage and the buyer’s brokerage. No law in New York fixes the commission rate, so every percentage on your listing agreement was negotiated, whether or not anyone said so out loud.

The rate you’re quoted depends on property type, price, and the services written into the agreement. Treat any published range as a starting point, not a quote.

What one percentage point costs at Manhattan prices

One point on the all-homes median of $1,329,367 is about $13,294. At the borough’s median sale-to-list ratio, a typical seller gives up about $6,647 off list. On a typical Manhattan sale, then, one commission point is worth roughly twice what the seller knocks off the asking price.

Multiply your own expected price by 0.01 for your per-point figure before you negotiate. Co-ops, condos, and houses trade at very different prices, so the median-based example is not your number.

Who Pays the Buyer’s Agent in Manhattan Now?

Since the 2024 rule changes, sellers choose between offering the buyer’s agent compensation to widen the buyer pool and keeping that money. The choice affects both how your property is marketed and how much you walk away with.

What the listing agreement sets

The exclusive listing agreement fixes the listing-side fee and, if you choose, any buyer-agent compensation. It also sets the term and any protection period, often called a tail clause. Ask your listing agent to write the commission as separate listing-side and buyer-side lines in the agreement.

A tail clause can leave you owing commission on a sale to a buyer introduced during the listing, even after it expires. Read that clause and the term length before you sign.

Offering buyer-agent compensation

Required practice changes under the NAR settlement agreement took effect on August 17, 2024. They eliminated offers of buyer-broker compensation on the MLS and required buyers working with an agent to sign a written agreement before touring homes, which spells out what their agent is owed.

Locally, starting January 1, 2024, REBNY’s Universal Co-Brokerage Agreement requires that offers of compensation to the buyside broker come directly from the seller or owner. Listing brokers are no longer permitted to make or pay that offer, even on the seller’s behalf.

With that much supply on the market, buyers have alternatives. Represented buyers may favor listings that cover their agent over a seller who offers nothing. Offering less saves money only if it doesn’t lengthen your marketing time or lower your price, and how a specific building’s buyers will react is hard to predict.

When buyers pay their own agent

Offers increasingly ask the seller for a concession or credit toward the buyer’s agent fee. That shifts the expense to a cost negotiated at the offer stage rather than at listing.

Deferring the buyer-agent question keeps your listing cheaper on paper. You may still pay the fee, but you negotiate it against a live offer rather than in advance.

How Property Type Changes the Commission Math

The same rate means very different dollars and different negotiating power depending on what you’re selling.

Condos and co-ops

Apartments make up nearly all Manhattan sales: 2,707 of the 2,836 homes sold recently. At the condo median of $1,274,869, one point is about $12,749, which makes the buyer-agent decision the main lever here.

Confirm whether your building is a condo or a co-op, because Redfin’s condo category may group both. Get the building’s sale charges, listed under the fees section below, before you work out net proceeds. Co-op buildings can add their own costs at sale, such as a flip tax or move-out fee, and board approval can stretch timelines.

Townhouses

Townhouses were the one Manhattan property type that sold above asking on average last quarter, coming in at 100.1% of list. One point at the townhouse median is about $23,850.

A seller here has a reasonable case for a tiered fee that pays the agent more only above a target price. That said, the figure rests on 84 sales across very different blocks and conditions, and median time on market was still 84 days. A tiered fee works in your favor only if your target price is realistic for your specific house.

Single-family homes

A typical Manhattan single-family sale last quarter took about five and a half months, with a median 166 days on market and 11.9 months of supply. Over a campaign that long, marketing spend, listing term, and price-reduction strategy matter as much as the percentage you’re paying.

One point at the single-family median is about $61,725, and at prices like these the higher state transfer tax rate applies. With only 38 sales behind these figures, one or two outlier deals can swing the median, and none sold above list. Ask for comparable sales on your street rather than relying on borough numbers.

How to Negotiate Commission in Manhattan

The fee structure you choose determines how much risk you carry versus how much the agent assumes.

Tiered and performance-based fees

A tiered commission uses a lower base rate up to an agreed price and a higher rate only on dollars above it. For illustration only, you might agree to a 4% total rate up to $2 million and the full typical rate on any amount above that. This aligns the agent’s payout with the list-to-sale outcome. You can also negotiate a lower total if the listing agent finds an unrepresented buyer.

A threshold set too high rewards nothing. One set too low pays a bonus for an ordinary result. Anchor the number to recent comparable sales, which your listing agent should show you in writing.

Flat-fee, discount, and no-agent options

Lower-fee models typically leave out full-service tasks like showings, pricing strategy, and board-package management for co-ops. Compare the scope line by line rather than by rate alone, and ask any discount or flat-fee provider which tasks you’d handle yourself. Selling without a listing agent still leaves the buyer-agent question open. Sellers who prioritize speed can also sell for cash directly to a buyer.

A lower rate can cost more than it saves if the home sits longer or sells further below list.

Other Seller Costs Besides Commission

Commission is not the only deduction from your proceeds. State and city transfer taxes and building-specific charges also take a share of the final price.

NYC and New York State transfer taxes

For Residential Type 1 or Type 2 sales or transfers in NYC, the Real Property Transfer Tax (RPTT) rate is 1% of the consideration if it is $500,000 or less, and 1.425% if the consideration is more than $500,000. Under NY Tax Law § 1402(a), the base state transfer tax is $2 per $500 of consideration (0.4%).

An additional $1.25 per $500 (0.25%) base tax applies in NYC when consideration for residential real property is $3 million or more. A separate mansion tax supplement applies at 1% to conveyances of residential real property starting at $1 million. For a $1.2 million sale, the seller pays the 1.425% city tax and 0.4% state tax. A $3.5 million sale triggers the higher state rate.

Transfer taxes are set by law and are not negotiable the way commission is. On a tight net-proceeds budget, the commission is usually the only large line you can move.

Attorney, building, and payoff fees

Sellers in New York customarily hire a real estate attorney to handle the closing, so get a flat-fee quote from one before estimating net proceeds. Ask your lender for the loan satisfaction or payoff fee. Ask the managing agent for the building’s current flip tax, move-out fee, and managing agent closing fee. These fees vary by building and lender and are rarely posted publicly, so get written figures before you work out your net.

Which Commission Terms to Negotiate First

Start with property type, because each has a different commission lever. For a condo or co-op it is the buyer-agent decision, for a townhouse a tiered fee, and for a single-family home the listing term and marketing scope. Go to your H3 under How property type changes the commission math.

Next, decide whether you will offer buyer-agent compensation in the listing, leave it to offers, or decline it. Offering buyer-agent compensation and When buyers pay their own agent set out that trade-off.

If you expect to sell near or above your list price, look at Tiered and performance-based fees. If a long marketing period is likely, focus on the listing term and marketing scope covered under Single-family homes.

Finally, if your likely price could reach the higher state rate, read NYC and New York State transfer taxes before settling on a commission.

Michael J. Franco can prepare a written commission and net-proceeds breakdown for a specific Manhattan property. This helps you see exact dollars before you sign a listing agreement.

At a Glance

  • All homes: median sale price $1,329,367, up 3.4% year over year (90 days ending 2026-09-30)
  • All homes: 2,836 sold; median 70 days on market; 99.5% sale-to-list; 14% sold above list (90 days ending 2026-09-30)
  • All homes: 6.1 months of supply; 5,660 homes for sale; median $1,442 per sq ft (90 days ending 2026-09-30)
  • Condo (Redfin category; check whether a given building is condo or co-op): median sale price $1,274,869, up 4.1%; 2,707 sold; median 69 days on market; 99.5% sale-to-list; 14.2% sold above list; 5.8 months of supply; median $1,448 per sq ft (90 days ending 2026-09-30)
  • Townhouse: median sale price $2,385,028, down 0.6%; 84 sold; median 84 days on market; 100.1% sale-to-list; 14.6% sold above list; 8 months of supply; median $1,310 per sq ft (90 days ending 2026-09-30)
  • Single family (based on 38 sales, so treat the 45.8% yearly change with caution): median sale price $6,172,539; median 166 days on market; 98.9% sale-to-list; 0% sold above list; 11.9 months of supply; median $1,494 per sq ft (90 days ending 2026-09-30)

Manhattan Real Estate Commission FAQs

How much commission do real estate agents in Manhattan keep?

Each brokerage’s share of the total is split again between the agent and their sponsoring broker. That split commonly ranges from 50/50 up to 90/10, depending on the agent’s experience and the firm’s compensation plan.

Will Manhattan agents accept a 2% commission?

Yes, commission is negotiable, and 2% on the condo median is about $25,497. Whether an agent accepts depends on the services included and whether that figure is meant to cover the buyer’s side as well.

Are realtor commissions in Manhattan still 6%?

That is still the typical Manhattan total, but no rate was ever required. Since the NAR settlement changes, buyer-agent pay is offered separately from the listing fee.

Is real estate commission included in closing costs in New York?

Yes, the commission is usually paid at closing out of the seller’s proceeds and appears as a deduction on your closing statement. Ask your attorney for a draft closing statement showing the commission, transfer taxes, and building fees as separate lines.

Do you still owe commission if a Manhattan sale falls through?

Under New York law, a broker is generally entitled to a commission when they produce a buyer ready, willing, and able to purchase on terms acceptable to the seller. A written agreement can change that default, for example by conditioning commission on closing of title, so check your contract’s payment trigger.

Is real estate commission tax deductible when you sell a home?

Not as a separate deduction. IRS Publication 523 lists sales commissions as a selling expense that reduces the amount realized on the sale, which lowers your capital gain. Ask a tax professional how this applies to your sale.

How long do listing agreements last in Manhattan?

Listing terms vary and are negotiable before you sign. A longer term of several months may be reasonable for single-family homes, which have the longest marketing times. Read the early termination terms before committing.

Sources